Goals:
1-0: Ritchie pen (10, stroked the spot-kick down the middle and into the net after Gouffran was brought down by the keeper)
2-0: Gouffran (35, controlled Shelvey’s free-kick with back to goal then flicked up and applied lovely finish on the turn)
2-1: Cotterill (71, dinked an effort over Sels after being picked out by Kieftenbeld’s nod down)
3-1: Ritchie (90, on hand to turn in another brilliant assist from Shelvey)
Bookings: Shotton (34, dissent); Tiote (69, foul)
Referee: Lee Probert (Swindon) – correctly kept Legzdins on the pitch after conceding the opening penalty and blew at the right times after that. 7
Attendance: 34, 896
Entertainment: ***
Newc Birm
Shots on 4 1
Shots off 9 11
Corners 6 5
Offsides 2 2
Fouls 10 5
NEWCASTLE UNITED (4-3-2-1):
6 Sels: Hard to remember him having much to do, certainly didn’t have many meaningful shots to deal with;
6 Yedlin: Straight-forward night down the right and was certainly helped by the probing Ritchie got through
6 Hanley: Will have harder nights in a Newcastle shirt and probably already has
6 Findlay: Can be satisfied with his first team debut after showing composure on the ball
6 Lazaar: Made the runs to help the younger man in front of him and defended well too;
8 SHELVEY: Ran the show from start to finish and a welcome return for Benitez
6 Tiote: Seemed to enjoy himself even if he was still well short of the standards he has set in the past
6 Barlaser: The locally produced talent made plenty of good runs and was confident on the ball;
8 Ritchie: Scored a penalty, found the post with a brilliant effort and added a second late on while his performance was decent throughout
6 El-Mhanni: A few glimpses of his skills, looked raw but certainly has potential if he can make the right decisions;
8 Gouffran: Won the penalty, hit the post and then scored himself with a lovely finish.
Subs:
Perez (for Ben El-Mahanni 70): Solid enough run out ahead of the league return on Saturday. 6
Hayden (for Yedlin 75)
Colback (for Tiote 82)
(not used): Elliot (gk), Dummett, Lascelles, Murphy.
BIRMINGHAM CITY (4-3-2-1): Legzdins 6; Dacres-Cogley 6, Shotton 6, Robinson 5, Grounds 4; Kieftenbeld 5 (Fabbrini 80), Davis 5 (Brown 64, 5), Tesche 4; Adams 6, COTTERILL 7; Solomon-Otabor 4 (Jutkiewicz 64, 7). Subs (not used): Kuszczak (gk), Gleeson, Morrison.
MAN OF THE MATCH
JONJO Shelvey – played as if he had never been away to remind everyone why he is so important for Newcastle this season.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here