A PLANNING chairman's casting vote has given the go-ahead to controversial plans to re-site a large building for use by landscape contractors in an area of outstanding natural beauty.

Councillors on an area planning committee of Harrogate Borough Council were split at 3-3, with chairman Councillor Nigel Simms (Masham) giving his casting vote in favour of the change.

The plan brought strong protests from a parish council and residents.

Grantley Parish Council, near Ripon, said the application by Snow Bros had created a great deal of concern and they had received many letters opposing the scheme.

Councillors were recommended to approve the scheme for the site, between Risplith and Grantley, at a former coal stock yard.

Earlier, permission was granted for a large building to be used by landscape contractors.

But the applicants want to move the approved building 9m to the west to secure a change of access.