Sir, - On January 30, in tragic circumstances, my wife Susan died. As subsequent days unfolded, it became increasingly apparent to her grieving family of husband, daughters Liz and Jen and younger sister Christine, herself recently widowed, that the loss extended far beyond our own introspective lives and that Susan Lumsden also belonged to the wider community in her capacity as teacher of French since 1980 at Thirsk Comprehensive School.

Not being involved in the teaching profession, it was not until her death that I was aware of the full depth of affection and high regard in which "Mrs Lumsden" was held.

Of course I knew she was a very good teacher, had a phenomenal memory for pupils past and present and took her pastoral responsibilities very seriously.

Our daughters, Liz and Jen, and I have many joyful memories of our life together at home, school and on holidays in France, all with her exuberance, laughter and common sense.

The purpose of this letter, however, is to address all those adults and pupils, many unknown to her family, who have expressed their condolences and appreciation of a much respected and loved teacher. We have been engulfed in flowers, letters, cards, telephone calls and offers of help and this was followed by the attendance at Harrogate Crematorium of mourners from far and near.

This has been of immeasurable support to us all. Through these columns I wish to express on behalf of Susan's family our deep and heartfelt thanks to you all - friends, colleagues, all school staff, pupils, past pupils and parents.

We are all immensely proud of the achievements of Susan; thank you.

DAVID LUMSDEN

Thirsk.

Off the wagon

Sir, - I am a new member to the Cleveland Police Authority, so I know no more about the Lancet enquiry than any other member of the public. Like most, I will base my judgement on statements given by the Chief Constable and by Mr Mallon. Press reports, with a premium on space, often do not give the full detail and therefore the facts can become somewhat distorted (as those of us who write letters to the editor are aware).

Each side has its supporters and detractors, but Ashok Kumar seems to fall into both camps, unlike Frank Cook and Stuart Bell who took note of both points of view. He trailed Mr Mallon round, lauding him as worthy of everyone's support.

Dr Kumar even attended a full meeting of Redcar and Cleveland Council when the Labour group proposed a motion supporting a demand to the Government to hold an inquiry into Lancet. Who was the instigator of that?

Now, having convinced people of the uprightness of Mr Mallon but in fear that he has damaged Labour's chances of having their candidate elected Mayor of Middlesbrough, he has withdrawn his support.

He jumped on a bandwagon but now it does not suit his own purpose, he has jumped off. What does that say about Ashok Kumar's judgement and integrity?

VALERIE HALTON

Conservative councillor, Redcar

and Cleveland Borough Council,

Guisborough.