Inmate says serious assault at HMP Durham was self-defence

The alleged assault was said to have taken place in a cell at HMP Durham in February last year <i>(Image: The Northern Echo)</i>
The alleged assault was said to have taken place in a cell at HMP Durham in February last year (Image: The Northern Echo)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

An inmate claims he carried out a serious assault on a fellow prisoner in self-defence, fearing he, too, would otherwise be attacked.

David Smith Warrender McLaughlin appeared at a Durham Crown Court plea hearing via video link from HMP Northumberland, where he is now serving a prison sentence.

Both the defendant and the complainant in the case were on remand in Durham Prison at the time of the alleged attack, on February 27 last year.

Following a brief conference with her client, Penny Hall, representing McLaughlin, said the charge could be put to him.

(Image: The Northern Echo) The 45-year-old defendant denied the single charge of wounding with intent to do the other inmate grievous bodily harm.

Judge Jo Kidd asked Miss Hall if there would be an offer of a plea to a lesser charge.

Miss Hall said there would not, as the defendant would be putting forward a case of “self-defence” at trial.

“His case is that he was attacked and defended himself.”

(Image: The Northern Echo) The case was adjourned for a trial, of two days’ duration, to take place at the court, on November 19 and 20.

A further case management hearing will take place on May 13.

Miss Hall said the defendant is now serving a prison sentence but is due for release in only a week’s time.

Read next ... further court coverage from The Northern Echo, by clicking here

'Dangerous' inmate slashed fellow Frankland prisoner across neck

Inmate facing lengthy sentences for attacks in Durham's HMP Frankland

Frankland prisoner threw boiling water and butter mix at fellow inmate

Martin Towers, prosecuting, said he had no instructions to seek to have the defendant further remanded upon his release, on February 19, ahead of the trial.

Judge Kidd, therefore, adjourned the case pending the pre-trial hearing in May and the trial, itself, in November and granted McLaughlin technical bail.

His bail correspondence address was given as Turnbull Close, Gilesgate, Durham.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos