A sheep farmer's plan to erect a half-mile long fence on moorland was turned down by a single vote yesterday.

Councillor Helen Schroeder, chairman of the National Park Authority, backed officers who opposed the move by Brian Aconley for a fence from Esklets to Farndale, on the North York Moors. They said it would be "an unacceptable intrusion" into the landscape.

However, the authority agreed to set aside £16,000 for cattle grids and a further £20,000 to help in providing additional shepherding.

Vice-chairman Councillor Herbert Tindall said there were growing worries that unless flocks were retained on the moors the thousands of acres of purple heather would be transformed into scrub trees and bracken.