Researchers from Durham University and Darlington Memorial Hospital reveal confusion over heart failure care

Darlington Memorial Hospital, which took part in the research

Darlington Memorial Hospital, which took part in the research

First published in News The Northern Echo: Photograph of the Author by

CARE of heart failure patients in the UK is inadequate and has not changed in a decade, North-East researchers have warned.

The startling findings by a team at Durham University and Darlington Memorial Hospital also highlights an uncoordinated approach to diagnosis and management of the condition.

The research - initiated and led by Darlington GP Ahmet Fuat - reveals clinicians are uncertain about how to diagnose different types of heart failure and over who has overall responsibility for heart failure management.

It uncovered an inconsistency in patients' access to tests and services and a lack of awareness by health professionals of dedicated heart failure clinics.

Medical staff also expressed concerns over how to care for heart failure patients affected by other diseases and taking other medicines.

The project - published by BMJ Open and funded by national charity Heart Research UK - calls for:

  • Development of clear lines of responsibility
  • Better education of GPs and non-heart specialist hospital doctors
  • Access to the high quality services and care pathways for all patients​

More than a million people are affected by heart failure in the UK, a problem which often goes undetected and under-treated

Between 2008 and 2010 there were 11,354 deaths in the North-East resulting from coronary heart disease (CHD) - a contributing factor to heart failure - and 23,373 deaths in Yorkshire and Humberside.

In 2010/11 the prevalence of CHD among registered GP patients in the North-East - 4.6 per cent - was the highest of any region in England.

The researchers interviewed GPs, cardiologists, physicians and heart failure nurses from across the North-East before compiling a wider national survey of health professionals to compare care across the UK.

Dr Fuat, whose previous work contributed to the setting up of a 'one stop' diagnostic heart clinic at Darlington Memorial, is an honourary clinical professor in the School of Medicine, Pharmacy and Health, at Durham University.

He said: "Even though the Government has spent a lot of money on improving heart services, some of the problems we were told about are the same as those ten years ago.

"This is worrying because it means we are still not getting things right for patients with heart failure."

Dr Helen Hancock, a health research methodologist at Durham University, added: "This is more about education than money.

"General physicians often don't know when they see a patient in whom they suspect heart failure what to do next.

"Everybody, GPs, heart failure nurses, cardiologists must have a clearer idea of their roles and we need a robust system of getting the right diagnosis from the off. It is not just a case of applying guidelines.

"There needs to be a clear pathway of care and the same high quality services must be available to all patients."

Darlington MP Jenny Chapman vowed to flag up the research and its findings to the Government.

She said: "I commend Professor Fuat for the work he has done and I will be happy to recommend this research and its findings to the Government.

"I am pleased that work to hopefully put right what is a neglected area is being done right here in the North-East."

  • The Northern Echo's Chance to Live campaign, launched in the 1990s, helped change Government policy over coronary care and highlighted concerns over long waiting lists.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

1:02am Wed 2 Apr 14

smokin says...

yes my son has just had open heart surgery in James Cook to remove a tumor that the doctors failed to detect.
for 8 months they treated him for chest infections/ re flux anything but his heart even though previous doctors said you have a heart murmur paramedic said you have an irregular heartbeat still they did nothing a scan would have been the order of the day surely ?
he would died if it wasn't for a locum doctor who sent him for a heart scan if this is down to money then doctors are playing with peoples lives and my son is only 45 years old
yes my son has just had open heart surgery in James Cook to remove a tumor that the doctors failed to detect. for 8 months they treated him for chest infections/ re flux anything but his heart even though previous doctors said you have a heart murmur paramedic said you have an irregular heartbeat still they did nothing a scan would have been the order of the day surely ? he would died if it wasn't for a locum doctor who sent him for a heart scan if this is down to money then doctors are playing with peoples lives and my son is only 45 years old smokin
  • Score: 2

8:56am Wed 2 Apr 14

mollydolly11 says...

My husband is 41 darlington hospital were rubbish this all started Christmas eve and he is just getting worse if could aford private care I would
My husband is 41 darlington hospital were rubbish this all started Christmas eve and he is just getting worse if could aford private care I would mollydolly11
  • Score: 1

9:51am Wed 2 Apr 14

bambara says...

The UK spends 2/3rd what France or Germany spend (as a % of GDP).
The NHS is underfunded, simple.
Tory propoganda will say it is inefficient, but for what we spend we have an extremely good rating by the World Health Organisation.
It is simply a that the Tories are trying to break up the NHS, and privatise it by the back door.

The NHS is not safe in Tory hands.
The UK spends 2/3rd what France or Germany spend (as a % of GDP). The NHS is underfunded, simple. Tory propoganda will say it is inefficient, but for what we spend we have an extremely good rating by the World Health Organisation. It is simply a that the Tories are trying to break up the NHS, and privatise it by the back door. The NHS is not safe in Tory hands. bambara
  • Score: 8

2:35pm Wed 2 Apr 14

smokin says...

mollydolly11 wrote:
My husband is 41 darlington hospital were rubbish this all started Christmas eve and he is just getting worse if could aford private care I would
if your husband isn't being given a "duty of care " then please complain and demand a second opinion what happened to my son was a disgrace that I won't let happen again these doctors think they know it all and they don't
I had been saying for months that it was his heart but no one listened if they don't know do what I did and google
I hope everything turns out ok for him
[quote][p][bold]mollydolly11[/bold] wrote: My husband is 41 darlington hospital were rubbish this all started Christmas eve and he is just getting worse if could aford private care I would[/p][/quote]if your husband isn't being given a "duty of care " then please complain and demand a second opinion what happened to my son was a disgrace that I won't let happen again these doctors think they know it all and they don't I had been saying for months that it was his heart but no one listened if they don't know do what I did and google I hope everything turns out ok for him smokin
  • Score: -2

2:17pm Thu 3 Apr 14

Madadrian says...

I have recently been discharged from the hospital after a heart attack. They kept me alive and after extensive testing arranged a continuous course of treatment.
I;m happy and still alive to be able to write this
I have recently been discharged from the hospital after a heart attack. They kept me alive and after extensive testing arranged a continuous course of treatment. I;m happy and still alive to be able to write this Madadrian
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree