Former Cleveland Police Chief Constable drops legal fight over his arrest

THE former chief constable of Cleveland Police and his deputy have dropped legal action over claims they were wrongfully arrested.

However Sean Price and Derek Bonnard said tonight that they intend to restart their civil claim at a later date.

The pair, along with the force's former solicitor Caroline Llewellyn, were detained for questioning following early morning raids on their homes in August 2011.

The raids were part of Operation Sacristy, an investigation into a number of people with current or past associations with Cleveland Police Authority and the manner in which the authority may have conducted some of its business.

In May 2012, the two men announced that they were to sue Keith Bristow, director general of the National Crime Agency in his capacity as head of Operation Sacristy, as well as three police forces - North Yorkshire, Warwickshire and West Yorkshire.

But today, (Monday, January 14) Rebian Solicitors in Leeds, confirmed that their claim for unlawful arrest and detention, trespass and breach of their human rights was being withdrawn.

A spokesman for Operation Sacristy said: "We note that their civil claim has now been withdrawn. We intended to defend their civil action against us and would have demonstrated in court that their arrest, the searches and their interviews were necessary, lawful and proportionate."

A claim against Mr Price and Mr Bonnard for the legal costs incurred in responding to their claim and for preparing to defend the legal action is now being considered.

However a spokesman for Mr Price and Mr Bonnard said: "We are able to confirm that as a result of further legal advice on timing issues, Mr Price and Mr Bonnard have taken the decision to discontinue their civil claim at this time.

"However, they fully intend to progress this matter to civil court in due course.

"Mr Price and Mr Bonnard continue to maintain that both their arrests and detention were unlawful and stand by their previous complaints about the actions of the respective forces.

"Indeed they have received strong legal opinion in support of this position. It is their intention that recommencement of proceedings will be made in the near future."

The decision was revealed on the same day that date of Mr Bonnard's misconduct hearing was announced.

It is due to start on March 4, and last for up to four weeks.

It relates to seven allegations of gross misconduct, and will be held in private.

The misconduct hearing follows a managed investigation carried out by the Independent Police Complaints Commission, following a referral from Cleveland Police Authority in August 2011.

One matter of potential gross misconduct has been deferred pending the outcome of the wider criminal investigation ongoing by Operation Sacristy.

Mr Bonnard remains suspended from duty.

Mr Price was dismissed from the force in October for gross misconduct after an eight day disciplinary hearing.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:09pm Mon 14 Jan 13

BLOBBY35 says...

trying to bully people into submission ? it has not worked so having to back treat !! just what they have been doing when in there police job ,
trying to bully people into submission ? it has not worked so having to back treat !! just what they have been doing when in there police job , BLOBBY35

10:28am Tue 15 Jan 13

st-george1 says...

The new Police Crime Commissioner says nothing, despite being heavily involved with the old Police Authority when all this talk of serious misconduct and corruption probe of Mr Price was taking place …
The allegations are …
- He made trips abroad, the necessity and expenditure of which have been questioned .
- He did not follow the force's corporate credit card policy, often failed to provide receipts, bought alcohol with it and spent money on items which were allegedly not appropriate from the public purse.
- In 2012 he obstructed a criminal investigation by refusing to provide access to information.
- In July 2009 he failed to declare a personal interest when he gave a reference for a post to an officer he was in a relationship with.
- In 2009 he did not report changes in his personal circumstances in accordance with force requirements.
- In October 2010 he provided false information to the media and public about his personal circumstances.
- He failed to follow policy when he was involved in a collision while driving his force-owned vehicle in March 2009, by allegedly not reporting the incident or ensuring it was investigated.
MAYBE he now believes he was NOT the victim of a conspiracy, manipulation, sharp practise or stitch-up !
The new Police Crime Commissioner says nothing, despite being heavily involved with the old Police Authority when all this talk of serious misconduct and corruption probe of Mr Price was taking place … The allegations are … - He made trips abroad, the necessity and expenditure of which have been questioned . - He did not follow the force's corporate credit card policy, often failed to provide receipts, bought alcohol with it and spent money on items which were allegedly not appropriate from the public purse. - In 2012 he obstructed a criminal investigation by refusing to provide access to information. - In July 2009 he failed to declare a personal interest when he gave a reference for a post to an officer he was in a relationship with. - In 2009 he did not report changes in his personal circumstances in accordance with force requirements. - In October 2010 he provided false information to the media and public about his personal circumstances. - He failed to follow policy when he was involved in a collision while driving his force-owned vehicle in March 2009, by allegedly not reporting the incident or ensuring it was investigated. MAYBE he now believes he was NOT the victim of a conspiracy, manipulation, sharp practise or stitch-up ! st-george1

1:15pm Tue 15 Jan 13

Graeme_r says...

The new Police Commissioner might be too busy with his other duties as a Midddlesbrough Councillor!
The new Police Commissioner might be too busy with his other duties as a Midddlesbrough Councillor! Graeme_r

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree