Council could pay six figure compensation bill to bullied ex-teacher

First published in News The Northern Echo: Photograph of the Author by

A CASH-STRAPPED council could foot a six figure compensation bill after admitting defeat in its efforts to overturn a ruling in the case of a bullied ex-teacher.

Durham County Council had applied for permission to the Court of Appeal to challenge the outcome of an employment appeal tribunal in respect of Karen Hall, but this has now been refused.

A fresh employment tribunal hearing – which is expected next year – will now decide the level of compensation to be paid to Mrs Hall, unless agreement can be reached between the two parties.

The Northern Echo understands this could be a six figure sum covering future career loss and pension rights and which will also take into account the council’s failure to implement previous recommendations in respect of the former teacher’s case.

Meanwhile, the council will have to pay Mrs Hall’s “substantial” legal costs,  on top of its own legal bill. It had already spent £11,068 on consultants to investigate the case.

The five year-long saga involving the council and Mrs Hall, from Hamsterley, County Durham, began in 2007 when she instigated employment tribunal proceedings over her treatment while she was employed at West Cornforth Primary School.

Related links

A year later a tribunal panel found that she had suffered 18 separate acts of victimisation, along with continuous and relentless bullying, and awarded her damages of more than £50,000.

She carried on working at the school, but was fired in August 2009 and brought a new claim based on her dismissal.

A review of the original judgement found that her selection for redundancy was caused by the council’s failure to implement the tribunal’s recommendations, as agreed, which included restoring her to the post of “literacy leader” and supporting an application for a headship qualification, and was therefore a consequence of the victimisation she suffered.

Durham County Council appealed those findings at an employment appeal tribunal, claiming they were “illogical and perverse” and unsupported by the evidence, but failed on all grounds.

The authority had hoped to overturn the findings at the Court of Appeal, but in her judgement appeal court judge Dame Janet Smith said: “It appears to me that the Employment Appeal Tribunal has dealt comprehensively and correctly with all the points raised before them and I can see no prospect that the Court of Appeal will find that the Employment Tribunal fell into error.”

Mrs Hall – described as a dedicated and committed teacher – has funded all her own costs to date. She is actively looking for work, but does not plan to return to teaching.

The 40-year-old does not want to comment publicly at this stage.

In a statement Colette Longbottom, head of legal and democratic services at Durham County Council, said: “Before taking any legal action the council is mindful of the potential financial implications involved.

“In this case, as proceedings are ongoing, we do not yet know what the final costs will be.

“We believed we raised some substantial points in the appeal application and we are disappointed with the ruling, but will not be seeking to appeal further.

“The matter will proceed in the Employment Tribunal unless a negotiated settlement can be reached.”

Comments (8)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:37am Thu 22 Nov 12

annbalou says...

Why didn't they just pay up when originally found guilty instead of trying to worm their way out of the ruling and therefore wasting more tax payers money, DCC never fail to amaze me.
Why didn't they just pay up when originally found guilty instead of trying to worm their way out of the ruling and therefore wasting more tax payers money, DCC never fail to amaze me. annbalou
  • Score: 2

11:03am Thu 22 Nov 12

frankyboy says...

What DCC should do is ensure that a robust system is in place to ensure that headteachers manage all their staff in a fair and equal manner, which is why they are paid huge sums of taxpayers money.
DCC should never just allow headteachers to be Caesar and to be able to treat their staff however they like, with no accountability.
What DCC should do is ensure that a robust system is in place to ensure that headteachers manage all their staff in a fair and equal manner, which is why they are paid huge sums of taxpayers money. DCC should never just allow headteachers to be Caesar and to be able to treat their staff however they like, with no accountability. frankyboy
  • Score: 0

11:09am Thu 22 Nov 12

Magic Steve says...

I hate any form of bullying and hope Mrs Hall gets Justice and the people which have done the bullying get their just deserts too!
I hate any form of bullying and hope Mrs Hall gets Justice and the people which have done the bullying get their just deserts too! Magic Steve
  • Score: 4

11:09am Thu 22 Nov 12

Magic Steve says...

I hate any form of bullying and hope Mrs Hall gets Justice and the people which have done the bullying get their just deserts too!
I hate any form of bullying and hope Mrs Hall gets Justice and the people which have done the bullying get their just deserts too! Magic Steve
  • Score: 4

12:17pm Thu 22 Nov 12

David Lacey says...

Schools should not be run by councils. Then the onus of responsibility would be placed fairly and squarely where it belongs.
Schools should not be run by councils. Then the onus of responsibility would be placed fairly and squarely where it belongs. David Lacey
  • Score: 0

5:14pm Thu 22 Nov 12

Duke of Aycliffe says...

Bullying in the workplace is wrong however, how many employees in the private sector would be in line for a six figure payout? No wonder our council tax is so high.
Bullying in the workplace is wrong however, how many employees in the private sector would be in line for a six figure payout? No wonder our council tax is so high. Duke of Aycliffe
  • Score: 0

11:28pm Thu 22 Nov 12

spragger says...

Why does the taxpayer always end up with the bill?
Those responsible should pay.

The taxpayer is a soft target

Think so called Council 'equality' payments
Why does the taxpayer always end up with the bill? Those responsible should pay. The taxpayer is a soft target Think so called Council 'equality' payments spragger
  • Score: 0

11:46pm Thu 22 Nov 12

G Harris says...

DCC not addressing bullying and victimising someone? Especially a woman? No surprise there then! Do they never learn and will they never change? It appears not.
DCC not addressing bullying and victimising someone? Especially a woman? No surprise there then! Do they never learn and will they never change? It appears not. G Harris
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree