A DECADE-long row between an internet tycoon and village residents over the future of an historic pub is back in the spotlight.

The North York Moors National Park authority's planning committee will on Thursday consider Freeserve founder Peter Wilkinson's revised proposals to convert the Plough Inn, at Fadmoor, near Helmsley, into two local occupancy homes to rent and four holiday homes.

Read more: Tributes to Jane who hand-fed wildlife and helped Dales red squirrels flourish

The 239-year-old building is a registered asset of community value but has been boarded up for years.

The conversion application was considered last July, but after being deferred to seek more information over a community request for compulsory purchase and a viability assessment, Mr Wilkinson has appealed to the Planning Inspectorate on the grounds of non-determination.

Consequently, the park authority can no longer determine the application, but it is required to advise the Planning Inspectorate as to whether it would have approved or refused the application.

Mr Wilkinson, who owns the 19,000-acre Pennyholme Estate to the north of the village, closed the pub, which featured in the Michelin Guide, in 2011 citing a lack of trade and villagers' access to a pub in nearby Gillamoor.

In support of the application, the applicant’s agents have stated: "We appreciate that the previous planning application for the change of use to ground floor offices was refused due to the property being registered as a community asset and lack of supporting information for the financially non-viability of the business.

"However, as the public house ceased trading in Jan 2011, and is now boarded up with no access for the public and therefore it makes no contribution to the community, it is clearly not a community asset."

However, local residents have insisted the pub could be a viable business and The Fadmoor Community Pub Ltd has continued to campaign to buy it and make it a multi-purpose community enterprise.

Residents have again objected to Mr Wilkinson's plans saying existing holiday accommodation businesses in the area would benefit greatly from having a pub in Fadmoor, which remained much-needed for use by residents.

In a letter of objection one resident wrote: "There appears to have been a concerted effort to ensure the decline of the building to the point that it can be claimed to be an eyesore and that redevelopment is the only solution."

A planning officers' report over the latest plans, states the community do appear to have the will and finances to purchase the closed pub if they were able to, and to run it successfully.

Read more: North Yorkshire murder probe: Police given more time to question man after woman's death

It adds: "The national park authority does not have the powers to force the owner to sell; it must restrict its consideration to its own planning policy position and whether or not a change of use would be supported.

"It would not benefit good planning delivery to continue to refuse alternative uses of these buildings that would have some community and economic benefit whilst also resolving a worsening physical /environmental problem in an attractive moors village.

"To do so, in the face of policies that would support the new uses proposed would be considered to be unreasonable and officers strongly advise that a refusal of this application would be difficult to justify."


Keep up to date with all the latest news on our website, or follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

You can also follow our dedicated North Yorkshire Facebook page for all the latest in the area by clicking here.

For all the top news updates from right across the region straight to your inbox, sign up to our newsletter here.

Have you got a story for us? Contact our newsdesk on newsdesk@nne.co.uk or contact 01325 505054