George Friend: The Bundesliga is in a league of its own

The Northern Echo: IN CHARGE: Borussia Dortmund's charismatic manager Jurgen Klopp IN CHARGE: Borussia Dortmund's charismatic manager Jurgen Klopp

AS Bayern Munich look to finish off the job against Arsenal in the Champions League tonight, Middlesbrough defender George Friend reflects on the Bundesliga success story

FOR the first time in Champions League history, all four German and English teams competing have made it through to the tournament’s last 16 - even if Manchester United, Arsenal, Manchester City and Chelsea could all slip out at this stage.

But with both nations dominating the group stages, their respective leagues have to take credit for the undisputed control and influence demonstrated, but who has the upperhand?

Germany is fast becoming the dominant, leading force in European football, unsurpassed on the pitch while exhibiting exemplary financial benchmarks off it.

The Premier League, seemingly untouchable, the football ‘shangri-la’ we Brits hold in such high regard, is about as significant as a Yorkshire pudding or cream tea to the average German football fan.

The dedication and fanaticism shown by fans towards the Premier League is undeniably astonishing. However it would be incredibly ignorant to believe we are alone in showcasing such passion on a similar scale towards a nation’s top football league.

In my opinion, the Germans have surpassed us and show no signs of stopping, like it or not British football lovers, but there’s every possibility that we are now lagging well behind, on both an international and domestic stage.

With two of its biggest clubs (Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund) in last season’s Champions League final, the Bundesliga also boasts the highest average attendance of the five major leagues in Europe.

Its success is apparently down to a ‘fan comes first’ policy and, quite possibly, the fact the league possesses the best players in the world right now.

The whole structure and approach of the Bundesliga seems to be the antithesis of its continental counterparts in Spain, Italy, France and, of course, England’s Premier League.

Although all the countries mentioned will argue that the fabric of their league follows a similar ethos whereby the ‘fan comes first,’ there is evidence that Germany remains successfully on top. In fact miles ahead of the pack.

In the Bundesliga, most of the stadiums that were built for the 2006 World Cup regularly host sell out crowds of happy, energetic German fans, whilst proudly upholding low ticket prices (the lowest out of Europe’s top five leagues).

Using one of last season’s most impressive and exciting teams in the whole of Europe as an example, Borussia Dortmund, their ticket prices certainly don’t reflect their success.

The Westfalenstadion, Dortmund’s stadium, is home to the largest stand in the world: ‘the yellow wall’, which seats 26,000 with an admittance charge of only £13 a ticket. When comparing this to our Premier League ticket prices, there is only going to be one nation’s set of fans with a stack of beer money in their back pocket.

In this time of global economic uncertainty and financial constraint it’s somewhat refreshing to learn that at least one league in football, the Bundesliga, runs smoothly enough for teams to make a profit, rather than the inevitable scares of administration and transfer embargos that surround our home leagues, many of whom are plagued by debt and borrowings. The implosion and devastating fall of Portsmouth and Glasgow Rangers come to mind.

Germany’s top league generated over €2bn in revenue last season with a post-tax profit of €55m. The League may produce less match-day revenue than the Premier League, but because the clubs are run sustainably and there is an unwritten promise that ticket prices will remain affordable without fluctuation, the league continues to prosper.

We are yet to see the influx of British players swarming into the German league, perhaps because most wage bills don’t match those in England or Spain. Some, Kevin Keegan for instance, have made the trip across to central Europe in the past, but it’s hardly been a memorable stomping ground for our home-grown players.

Are English players, from our illustrious Premier League, good enough to grace the Bundesliga’s elite? Perhaps not!

When you scratch the surface and delve beyond the Manchester sides, Arsenal and Chelsea, our famed Premier League begins to lose its world-class recognition.

Football great Zinedine Zidane is an advocate of the German/Bayern movement, having publically expressed his opinion on who should have won the Ballon D’Or award.

He said: ‘I would give it to Franck (Ribery) because he was fundamental in the three trophies that Bayern won last season.’

There’s further strength and depth, aside from Bayern Munich in the Bundesliga. The threats of Borussia Dortmund, Schalke 04, Bayern Leverkusen and SV Werder Bremen, are just a handful of tongue-twizzling yet exciting, dangerous sides that make up the League.

Importantly the Bundesliga is a true exponent of youth development and demonstrates the resurgence of home grown players regularly breaking through.

Whether or not you have seen a Bundesliga match it’s inevitable that the teams involved are likely to display a cultured, entertaining performance that has been heavily developed from their stereotypical defensive and efficient past.

So much so that one of the world’s best managers, Pep Guardiola, has embarked on a career in Germany this season at Bayern Munich. As a football purist and true architect of the beautiful game, surely he had a pick of any league at his disposal after leaving Barcelona.

As the game’s founders and a passionate and patriotic footballing nation, it might be difficult and onerous for England to praise Germany for their success.

Nevertheless the Bundesliga deserves huge plaudits and our serious attention, as it doesn’t just begin to outshine our precious Premier League, it might in fact have already eclipsed it.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:48am Tue 11 Mar 14

Ezetiger10 says...

Apart from Munich and Dortmund who else has impressed in the champions league? The German league is improving but to say it better than premier league u must be high! Pure example of how over rated it is look at the embarrassing and I say embarrassing with greatest respect to the league in terms of producing technical players but the likes of Leverkusen and schalke were humiliated and exposed and this is the true reflection of this league! It's crap and has 2 great teams and even Dortmund are slowly dismantling and 1 by 1 the players are leaving for bayern and I would say top teams like Real Madrid will slowly take that team apart until they need to start again and bring in the youth... Whist the premiere league this season has under achieved we have 7 -8 teams that are very difficult teams to beat and can beat anyone on there day.. It's hard to see this with any other league. Mourinho and co have admitted it's the best league in the world because it's the most competitive. So no I don't agree with this article at all!
Apart from Munich and Dortmund who else has impressed in the champions league? The German league is improving but to say it better than premier league u must be high! Pure example of how over rated it is look at the embarrassing and I say embarrassing with greatest respect to the league in terms of producing technical players but the likes of Leverkusen and schalke were humiliated and exposed and this is the true reflection of this league! It's crap and has 2 great teams and even Dortmund are slowly dismantling and 1 by 1 the players are leaving for bayern and I would say top teams like Real Madrid will slowly take that team apart until they need to start again and bring in the youth... Whist the premiere league this season has under achieved we have 7 -8 teams that are very difficult teams to beat and can beat anyone on there day.. It's hard to see this with any other league. Mourinho and co have admitted it's the best league in the world because it's the most competitive. So no I don't agree with this article at all! Ezetiger10
  • Score: -3

2:09pm Tue 11 Mar 14

Ezetiger10 says...

How can a team be 20 points clear with 14 games to go and u claim its a very strong league!! Even the best barca team a few years ago was not clear of winning so early and so far ahead. U claim Dortmund are top team, but if there so great why are they so far behind bayern ? I'm not suggesting Dortmund are rubbish but I believe they are well over rated. Arsenal already beaten them in there own back yard.. If u remember last season they sneaked through with a last min defected goal against Malaga ! Yes they beat real in the semi comprehensively but they had that momentum as did liverpool and Porto with there over achievements in the champions league. They have some exceptional players just like Porto did and liverpool few years back but to suggest they are a world class team and come from a top top league it's just not true. Next season u will see if the bundesliga can take. 4 teams in the last 16 again. They shouldn't even have 4 teams entering as there league only has 18 teams! It may be a league that has the best fans but quality is nowhere near close to the premier league. Teams like hull city or Swansea battle with even the top teams not to forget the teams just outside the top 4!
How can a team be 20 points clear with 14 games to go and u claim its a very strong league!! Even the best barca team a few years ago was not clear of winning so early and so far ahead. U claim Dortmund are top team, but if there so great why are they so far behind bayern ? I'm not suggesting Dortmund are rubbish but I believe they are well over rated. Arsenal already beaten them in there own back yard.. If u remember last season they sneaked through with a last min defected goal against Malaga ! Yes they beat real in the semi comprehensively but they had that momentum as did liverpool and Porto with there over achievements in the champions league. They have some exceptional players just like Porto did and liverpool few years back but to suggest they are a world class team and come from a top top league it's just not true. Next season u will see if the bundesliga can take. 4 teams in the last 16 again. They shouldn't even have 4 teams entering as there league only has 18 teams! It may be a league that has the best fans but quality is nowhere near close to the premier league. Teams like hull city or Swansea battle with even the top teams not to forget the teams just outside the top 4! Ezetiger10
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree