Why it's unfair that Alan Pardew's comments have come back to haunt him

OUT OF CONTEXT: Newcastle United manager Alan Pardew has faced criticism for quotes bemoaning Arsenal's lack of English players in 2006 - should those quotes apply now?

OUT OF CONTEXT: Newcastle United manager Alan Pardew has faced criticism for quotes bemoaning Arsenal's lack of English players in 2006 - should those quotes apply now?

First published in Sport
Last updated
The Northern Echo: Photograph of the Author by

THE internet is a wonderful resource, but one of its inherent problems is that the past is only ever a click away.

Something that was said five, ten, even 20 years ago can be retrieved, reposted and presented as a diametric opposite to the present. Times and circumstances might change, but words are etched in the cyberspace equivalent of stone, enduring for decades on end.

That can be a particular problem for football managers, who get through so many comments in an average season that 'the truth' must always be regarded as a somewhat flexible concept.

Every time a manager speaks in a pre or post-match press conference, they are conversing with a wide range of constituencies. The fans, their players, the board of directors, the managers of opposing teams – all get a slightly different message depending on the circumstances at that precise moment.

Within a week, or even in a day in the helter-skelter of the transfer window, their words can be redundant. Yet thanks to the internet, they never completely disappear.

So as Newcastle United were busily adding to their growing French contingent this week, the world of social media was buzzing with some comments made by Alan Pardew when he was manager of West Ham United in 2006.

After Arsenal had failed to include a single English player in a Champions League game against Real Madrid, Pardew said: “I saw a headline saying Arsenal are flying the flag for Britain. I kind of wondered where that British involvement actually was when I looked at their team.

“It's important that top clubs don't lose sight of the fact that it's the English Premier League and English players should be involved. We have a young team at West Ham and we are proud to have so many Englishmen.”

Should a statement made in 2006 be used as an implicit criticism of Newcastle's current signing policy? Of course not. Yet it has been in some quarters, even though the world Pardew inhabits has completely changed.

Back then, he was attempting to defend a West Ham side that were attempting to kick on from mid-table with a group of largely English players. He was probably trying to score some points against Arsene Wenger and might even have been gently nudging his employers to continue with the investment model he had planned.

Either way, there was a context to the comments that simply does not exist now. Does that mean he believed in them in any less then? No. Does it mean he is not allowed to alter his opinion now that circumstances have changed? Almost seven years on, that would be ridiculous.

For a start, Pardew now finds himself as part of a wider recruitment team at Newcastle. He will have had a significant input into the acquisition of Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa, Yoan Gouffran and Massadio Haidara, but he is no longer master of all he surveys.

Managing director Derek Llambias, chief scout Graham Carr and club secretary Lee Charnley are all influential figures when it comes to developing and enacting a recruitment policy, and the ultimate buck stops with owner Mike Ashley.

To a large degree, the model is devised from above and Pardew has to work within it. His views matter, but they are not the only ones to have been aired this month.

Yet even if the Newcastle boss was still to prefer an English core – and there is no contemporary evidence to suggest this is the case – there are valid financial and footballing reasons to justify the route he has taken.

In Mathieu Debuchy (£4.5m) and Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa (£6.7m), Newcastle have secured two established France internationals for a little over £11m. Tottenham wanted more than that for Michael Dawson alone. Middlesbrough received £3m for full-back Joe Bennett, and he had played in just one Premier League fixture.

Buying English players is hideously expensive, and a club like Newcastle, who are attempting to balance the books, cannot justify prioritising the domestic market above foreign leagues, particularly France's Ligue 1 where they have established deep and effective networks.

In an ideal world, perhaps we'd all love to follow Sir John Hall's model of “11 Geordies wearing the black-and-white shirt”, but that is simply not realistic. And even if it was, who is to say that English players would be more successful, committed or loyal than the French signings that have arrived this week? Nile Ranger is English, but would you really want 11 players like him in your team?

The proof will be in the pudding, but while there is a valid debate to be had about the effect of so many overseas players on the England national team, that is not a discussion that should trouble Pardew or Llambias, who are employed to do their best for Newcastle United.

The pair have assessed all the available options, and concluded that this is the best way to go at the moment. In seven years time, it might not be, so whatever Pardew says in the next few weeks should not be interpreted as a blueprint for all of his dealings in the future.

In the past, yesterday's newspaper used to be tomorrow's fish-and-chip wrapper. It's hard to package your cod in a computer screen, but when it comes to the world of online news, the same general principle should still apply.

**

CHAMPS OF THE WEEK
BRADFORD CITY
The League Two club completed a fairytale journey to Wembley when they saw off Aston Villa in the semi-final of the Capital One Cup. The Bantams have suffered some hard times since dropping out of the Premier League, but their long-suffering fans have finally been rewarded.

CHUMP OF THE WEEK
EDEN HAZARD
There are suggestions the errant ball boy at Chelsea's Capital One Cup semi-final with Swansea was indulging in some pre-planned time wasting when he fell on the ball. Even so, quite what Hazard thought he was doing when he booted him in the midriff is baffling.

PERFORMANCE OF THE WEEK
SLOANE STEVENS BEATS SERENA WILLIAMS AT THE AUSTRALIAN OPEN
In years to come, Stevens' 3-6, 7-5, 6-4 defeat of Williams could be regarded as the changing of the guard in women's tennis. The American teenager performed superbly as she confirmed her arrival into the very top tier of the game.

TIP OF THE WEEK
Provided Cheltenham's Trials Day meeting survives the weather tomorrow, it should be a cracker. Sprinter Sacre should confirm his well-being ahead of the Festival, but the best bet could be The New One in the trial for the Neptune Novices' Hurdle.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:16pm Fri 25 Jan 13

The Fuhrer says...

"Should a statement made in 2006 be used as an implicit criticism of Newcastle's current signing policy? Of course not."

Ah, the vipers of the Jewish press. 2006 is 200 hundred years ago? 100 years? If Pardew believes the English Premier League should involve English players (which is correct I think) then he believes this. So it is correct he should now be criticised. Of course he should.

But Newcastle is a wee club from the North East of England. But I hope one day you will play the greatest club in the world - Bayern Munich - and we will give a warm welcome to the warm Geordies. Sieg Al! (Al Shearer)
"Should a statement made in 2006 be used as an implicit criticism of Newcastle's current signing policy? Of course not." Ah, the vipers of the Jewish press. 2006 is 200 hundred years ago? 100 years? If Pardew believes the English Premier League should involve English players (which is correct I think) then he believes this. So it is correct he should now be criticised. Of course he should. But Newcastle is a wee club from the North East of England. But I hope one day you will play the greatest club in the world - Bayern Munich - and we will give a warm welcome to the warm Geordies. Sieg Al! (Al Shearer) The Fuhrer
  • Score: 0

9:54pm Fri 25 Jan 13

vercingetorix says...

times and circumstances change...I remember saying I'd never get a computer ....or a mobile phone !
times and circumstances change...I remember saying I'd never get a computer ....or a mobile phone ! vercingetorix
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree