Soldiers hit back at BBC investigation into base

UNDER COVER: The BBC’s Russell Sharp

UNDER COVER: The BBC’s Russell Sharp

First published in News The Northern Echo: Photograph of the Author by , Regional Chief Reporter

SERVING soldiers have defended the treatment of young recruits and criticised the BBC for sending an undercover reporter into a military base.

More than 100 comments about documentary, The Undercover Soldier, were left on the unofficial Army Rumour Service website after the BBC revealed details of its show yesterday.

In the programme, recruits complain of being battered, punched, kicked and urinated on by instructors at the Infantry Training Centre, in Catterick Garrison, North Yorkshire.

One recruit told the undercover reporter that he was hit repeatedly in the head.

Another said his hand was so badly injured after being assaulted that he could not salute properly.

However, soldiers and former soldiers commenting on the site defended the behaviour of instructors.

One comment reads: “The whole idea of an Army is to defend your own soil and to kill the enemy.

“If we send a bunch of soft mummy’s boys in, what chance would they have?”

Another site member says: “Infantry training needs to be robust.

Unfortunately, what we class as robust will be seen to some as bullying.”

A third comment reads: “If people do happen to be outraged at a young recruit being toughened up for service, then all that shows is how soft this nation has become.”

The BBC is criticised by site members for sending an undercover reporter into the base.

“It’s a shame mainstream TV/media can’t put as much effort into informing the public what service personnel are doing in various theatres around the globe, and the pressures and problems that go with it,” says one member.

However, there was also support for the BBC’s decision to conduct its investigation.

One comment reads: “As I supported the journalist going through the police recruit training a couple of years ago, and showing how racist and corrupt they were, I can’t really complain when they do the same to the Army with, hopefully, a different result.”

Another visitor adds: “(Training) should involve pain, hardship and discomfort – it shouldn’t involve abuse and bullying.”

No one from the BBC was available to comment last night.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

6:36am Sat 20 Sep 08

darlodave says...

Stop critising our armed forces in what they do, which is a damned good job in today's society. We need to have a tough, stand up and be counted armed force and by being tough during training which or whatever way it takes will prove in the end. Some of the critics have no idea what the armed forces have to face in areas of conflict where any person approached toady can be the enemy and a robust form of training all helps to give the foot soldier his confidence. I've just witnessed a contingent of US armed forces on R & R and the sight of those guys, tough and ready, put the frightners up me. Praise to our armed forces all and one.
Stop critising our armed forces in what they do, which is a damned good job in today's society. We need to have a tough, stand up and be counted armed force and by being tough during training which or whatever way it takes will prove in the end. Some of the critics have no idea what the armed forces have to face in areas of conflict where any person approached toady can be the enemy and a robust form of training all helps to give the foot soldier his confidence. I've just witnessed a contingent of US armed forces on R & R and the sight of those guys, tough and ready, put the frightners up me. Praise to our armed forces all and one. darlodave
  • Score: 0

2:30am Sun 21 Sep 08

darlolady says...

lol @ darlodave "Stop criticising our armed forces in what they do", when you know what you’re talking about leave a comment. I hope it’s never you son/daughter that dies linked to bullying in the armed forces. Big difference between being tough and bullying, they need to be accountable for their actions never mind brushing it under that carpet and you need to have a reality check!!!
lol @ darlodave "Stop criticising our armed forces in what they do", when you know what you’re talking about leave a comment. I hope it’s never you son/daughter that dies linked to bullying in the armed forces. Big difference between being tough and bullying, they need to be accountable for their actions never mind brushing it under that carpet and you need to have a reality check!!! darlolady
  • Score: 1
Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree