Airport fears passengers will take flight to independent Scotland

The Northern Echo: NEW DAWN: Airport fears over Scottish independence NEW DAWN: Airport fears over Scottish independence

LOWER passenger taxes in an independent Scotland would harm the North-East’s major airport, it was claimed today.

Newcastle International Airport fears large numbers of travellers would choose to fly from north of the Border if air passenger duty is cut after September’s independence referendum.

Scottish transport minister Keith Brown has said that an SNP-run independent Scotland would immediately halve air passenger duty (APD) “with a view to abolishing it completely”.

The duty on an economy class seat currently stands between £13 and £97 per passenger.

Managers at Newcastle Airport fear that some of its 4.4m passengers a year would opt for cheaper flights from Scottish rival Edinburgh if duty is cut, with the loss particularly felt on long haul flights such as the Dubai route.

Graeme Mason, planning and corporate affairs director, said Newcastle Airport did not take a position on which way the Scottish people should vote in the referendum, but said the UK Government should be aware of its potential impact on the region.

He said: “If APD in Scotland is abolished or significantly reduced, cheaper flights from Scottish airports will distort the market, resulting in large numbers of passengers from the North of England travelling across the border.

“This will reduce our connectivity and damage our economy.

“The UK Government should resist the inclusion of APD in a devo-max settlement either before or after the referendum”.

He added that if Scotland votes for independence, “We call upon the UK Government to match any reductions introduced in Scotland to avoid market distortion and an unfair economic disadvantage to the North of England.

“If they don’t do this, the North of England is going to be at a serious disadvantage to the rest of Scotland.”

However, pro-independence group Business For Scotland says the region would benefit from increased investment if Scotland abolished the duty.

Spokesman Ivan Mckee said: "Scotland is doing what it should be doing; we're bringing ourselves into line with other countries across Europe who have much lower levels of Air Passenger Duty than we currently have.

"It's the best thing for the Scottish economy to do, and a growing Scottish economy would be good for the northeast of England.”

Aviation expert John Strickland, of analysts JLS Consulting, agreed that some passengers could switch airports if duty was cut.

He said: “There is certainly an overlap in the catchment areas of Edinburgh and Newcastle.

“Customers will typically prefer to fly from their local airport, but when there is a big price differential, which could be the case if APD was reduced or cancelled in Edinburgh but not in Newcastle, a number of customers could switch their travel plans”.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:14pm Tue 10 Jun 14

pensioner2 says...

Its a canny hike from Newcastle airport to Edinburghs airport to save £13. If it was a whole family and the savings were £97 a person it might be worthwhile, but you have to take into account the extra time and cost of travelling with the whole family all the way to edinburgh (especially with the cost of train travel). The arguments supplied by Newcastle airport for a reduction in air passenger duty, would equally apply to Durham Tees Valley because if newcastle received a reduction it woul be unfair on TSV which is only 40 miles away (far less than the approx 150-200 miles to Edingurgh airport, so if Newcastle gets a air passenger duty reduction so should DTV. otherwise we face losing DTV altogether (if we don't already, with the sneaky underhand Peel Airports in charge) with newcastle being even cheaper than it is already than DTV (how can it be cheaper to fly from newcastle to amsterdam than it is from DTV to Amsterdam and yet the sad fact is that it is a lot cheaper- thanks Peel airports your doing a really terrible job of promoting DTV!!)
Its a canny hike from Newcastle airport to Edinburghs airport to save £13. If it was a whole family and the savings were £97 a person it might be worthwhile, but you have to take into account the extra time and cost of travelling with the whole family all the way to edinburgh (especially with the cost of train travel). The arguments supplied by Newcastle airport for a reduction in air passenger duty, would equally apply to Durham Tees Valley because if newcastle received a reduction it woul be unfair on TSV which is only 40 miles away (far less than the approx 150-200 miles to Edingurgh airport, so if Newcastle gets a air passenger duty reduction so should DTV. otherwise we face losing DTV altogether (if we don't already, with the sneaky underhand Peel Airports in charge) with newcastle being even cheaper than it is already than DTV (how can it be cheaper to fly from newcastle to amsterdam than it is from DTV to Amsterdam and yet the sad fact is that it is a lot cheaper- thanks Peel airports your doing a really terrible job of promoting DTV!!) pensioner2
  • Score: 1

7:58pm Tue 10 Jun 14

behonest says...

If it saves me paying this awful tax, with a lower total cost, then I'd definitely consider Edinburgh or Glasgow. Almost certainly for long haul flights.
If it saves me paying this awful tax, with a lower total cost, then I'd definitely consider Edinburgh or Glasgow. Almost certainly for long haul flights. behonest
  • Score: 1

10:56pm Tue 10 Jun 14

MSG says...

Travelling form Scotland to the UK or the EU would be international travel with proper duty free as Scotland would not be part of the EU or the British Union ! You would also have to show your UK passport north of Berwick or Carlisle to enter the foreign nation to the north of us !
Travelling form Scotland to the UK or the EU would be international travel with proper duty free as Scotland would not be part of the EU or the British Union ! You would also have to show your UK passport north of Berwick or Carlisle to enter the foreign nation to the north of us ! MSG
  • Score: 0

7:29am Wed 11 Jun 14

fox1 says...

Independence in Scotland isn't going to happen, come September the canny Scots will show SNP they want to be part of the United Kingdom, not foreigners .
Independence in Scotland isn't going to happen, come September the canny Scots will show SNP they want to be part of the United Kingdom, not foreigners . fox1
  • Score: -2

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree