Miliband: Living standards are down

LIVING STANDARDS DOWN: Ed Miliband

LIVING STANDARDS DOWN: Ed Miliband

First published in News

THE Chancellor spoke for almost an hour but failed to mention people's living standards have fallen under the Tories, Labour leader Ed Miliband claimed today.

Replying to the Budget, Mr Miliband was interrupted by Government MPs noisily shouting after just 18 seconds.

But he told the Commons: "The Chancellor spoke for nearly an hour but he did not mention one central fact: the working people of Britain are worse off under the Tories.

"Living standards down, month after month, year after year."

Labour MPs chanted "down" as their leader worked through statistics for the years of the coalition Government.

And Mr Miliband said: "Since the election working people's living standards - £1,600 a year down. You are worse off under the Tories.

"Their 2010 manifesto promised 'an economy where people's standard of living rises steadily and sustainably'.

"But they have delivered exactly the opposite. Standards of living not rising steadily and sustainably, but falling sharply and steeply.

"And today you simply reminded people of the gap between your rhetoric and the reality of people's lives.

"Living standards falling for 44 out of 45 months under this Prime Minister, unmatched since records began. No amount of smoke and mirrors can hide it.

"And we already know the answer to the question millions of people will be asking in 2015 - are they better off now than they were five years ago?

"The answer is no. Worse off, much worse off, worse off under the Tories."

Mr Miliband took aim at the "same old Tories" for giving City bankers who earn £5 million a year a £200,000 annual tax cut while freezing pay for thousands of nurses last week, denying them a £250 increase.

The Labour leader said: "If you're a City banker earning £5 million and you're feeling the squeeze, don't worry because the Government feel your pain.

"Because this year that City banker was given a tax cut, not just any tax cut - £664 a day, £20,000 a month, a tax cut worth more than £200,000 a year.

"So the Prime Minister chooses to afford a tax cut worth £200,000 a year for that banker but he can't afford a pay rise of £250 a year for a nurse.

"These are the people who have the nerve to tell us 'We're all in this together'.

"It's Tory values, it's Tory choices, it's same old Tories."

The Opposition leader said the country should not be "grateful" that Mr Osborne plans a surplus for 2018/19 because he promised the deficit would be clear by 2014/15.

Mr Miliband also took aim at a number of the Chancellor's promises in the earlier days of the coalition.

He said: "Back in 2010 you told us that at the end of 2014 the economy would have grown by nearly 12%.

"Today the figures say it's been barely half that, and you want the country to be grateful.

"Back in 2010 you said the Government would clear the deficit in this Parliament by 2014/15.

"Today you want the country to be grateful because you said you can do it by 2018/19.

"Three years ago the Chancellor told us in his 2011 Budget speech he would deliver an economy 'carried aloft by the march of the makers'.

"But what's actually happened since then to the rebalancing that you promised?

"Manufacturing output has fallen by 1.3%, construction output has fallen by 4.2%, infrastructure investment down by 11%, every time you come to this House and you promise a rebalancing and every time you fail."

Mr Miliband derided the increase in the tax-free personal income allowance as "a classic Tory con" because they are "giving with one hand and taking away with the other" with 24 tax rises since 2010.

He said: "It's the same old Tory trick. You didn't tell us the rest of the story. You didn't mention the 24 tax rises introduced since you became Chancellor.

"You forgot to mention you put up VAT, you taxed away child benefit, you raised insurance tax, and gave us the granny tax.

"It's a classic Tory con, give with one hand and take far more away with the other. Same old Tories."

Mr Miliband said the Government had overseen the "lowest housebuilding since the 1920s" while rents have risen twice as fast as wages.

He said: "At the heart of the argument we have over the next 14 months is this question: whose recovery is it under the Tories? Under them it's a recovery for the few, not the many.

"Bankers' pay in London is rising five times faster than the pay of the average worker.

"This recovery is not working for working people, whose living standards are falling.

"It's not working for millions of women who see the gap between men and women's pay rising.

"They don't want to talk about the low-paid workers promised a £7 minimum wage by the Chancellor and given just 19p an hour.

"Under this Government it's an economy of the privileged, by the privileged, for the privileged."

Mr Miliband claimed the Government wanted to tell people the opposite of what is happening in their lives.

He said this included informing the public that their wages are increasing when they are falling, adding: "Just like they tell people energy bills are falling when they are rising. And they tell people they are better off but everyone knows the truth.

"You can change the shape of the pound but it doesn't matter if the pound is square, round or oval - if you're £1,600 worse off, you're still £1,600 a year worse off. You're worse off under the Tories."

Mr Miliband insisted the Government believes Britain succeeds with "low wages, low skills , insecure work".

He added that today's Budget did not deliver the long-term changes required in banking, housing and energy.

Mr Miliband went on: "We know what their long-term plan is - more tax cuts for the richest while everyone else gets squeezed."

He turned to Mr Osborne's reported comments that people who pay 40p tax should be happy, adding: "So this is the new Osborne tax theory - if you're in the middle paying 40p, you should be pleased to pay more.

"But if you're at the top paying 50p, you should be helped to pay less. Same old Tories.

"It's no wonder even if their own side think they're totally out of touch and even now after all the embarrassment of the millionaires' tax cut, they won't rule out going further."

Mr Miliband called on Mr Osborne and Mr Cameron to nod their heads if they plan to rule out a further cut to the top rate of income tax from 45p to 40p.

The Labour leader said Prime Minister David Cameron was an "expert in re-branding", telling MPs: "Remember the huskies, the bike, the tree?

"That was before they said cut the green crap.

"What is the latest re-branding from the Bullingdon Club? It's beyond parody because what does this lot now call themselves? They call themselves the Workers' Party.

"And who is writing the manifesto for this Workers' Party. We have a helpful answer from one Conservative MP - there are six people writing the manifesto, five went to Eton.

"So by my count there are more Etonians writing the manifesto than there are women in the Cabinet. No girls allowed."

Mr Miliband said today's Budget was proof the country is "worse off" under the Tories.

In reference to Education Secretary Michael Gove's comments last week about the "ridiculous" number of Etonians in Mr Cameron's inner circle, he said: "You know you're in trouble when the Education Secretary calls you a bunch of 'out of touch' elitists."

Mr Miliband told the Commons: "We don't need a party for the privileged few, we need a party for the many.

"That is why Labour will freeze energy bills, guarantee jobs for young people, cut business rates, reform the banks, get 200,00 homes built a year and abolish the bedroom tax.

"This is the Budget that confirms that people are worse off under the Tories - a worse-off Budget from an out of touch Chancellor. Britain can do better than them. Britain needs a Labour government."

Comments (14)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

4:27pm Wed 19 Mar 14

David Lacey says...

And Miliband forgot to mention how his mates crashed the economy by 7.2% in 2008. Or ran up a record deficit and debt. Or let in record numbers of immigrants putting millions out of work. Or saw our education standards slip below most of the developed world.
.
Fact is it was a wickedly political budget that has Labour well and truly stuffed.
And Miliband forgot to mention how his mates crashed the economy by 7.2% in 2008. Or ran up a record deficit and debt. Or let in record numbers of immigrants putting millions out of work. Or saw our education standards slip below most of the developed world. . Fact is it was a wickedly political budget that has Labour well and truly stuffed. David Lacey
  • Score: 6

4:59pm Wed 19 Mar 14

Red rose lad says...

Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.
Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create. Red rose lad
  • Score: 6

5:06pm Wed 19 Mar 14

laboursfoe says...

I think it's pathetic that the best attack he can come up with is an example using a banker on £5m.

Labour keep taking about taxcuts for millionaires. But there are many many more that earn well below £1m that will benefit form the turnaround in Labours final tax fling.

Also, he mentioned that the Tories had implements 24 tax rises. Fair enough, I think a good few of them are aimed at people earning higher rate tax (including MP's), thats more 'in it together' than not!!
I think it's pathetic that the best attack he can come up with is an example using a banker on £5m. Labour keep taking about taxcuts for millionaires. But there are many many more that earn well below £1m that will benefit form the turnaround in Labours final tax fling. Also, he mentioned that the Tories had implements 24 tax rises. Fair enough, I think a good few of them are aimed at people earning higher rate tax (including MP's), thats more 'in it together' than not!! laboursfoe
  • Score: 3

5:14pm Wed 19 Mar 14

mixxer says...

It's part of the political charade for the leader of the Opposition to criticise a budget. If, and I mean "IF", New Labour form the next Government, Miliband will continue very much in the same vein as Osbourne.
It's part of the political charade for the leader of the Opposition to criticise a budget. If, and I mean "IF", New Labour form the next Government, Miliband will continue very much in the same vein as Osbourne. mixxer
  • Score: 2

5:25pm Wed 19 Mar 14

DURHAM CITY says...

Labour are off their rockers crazy fools
Labour are off their rockers crazy fools DURHAM CITY
  • Score: 5

5:25pm Wed 19 Mar 14

Jonn says...

Red rose lad wrote:
Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.
Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.
[quote][p][bold]Red rose lad[/bold] wrote: Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.[/p][/quote]Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either. Jonn
  • Score: 1

5:56pm Wed 19 Mar 14

loan_star says...

Jonn wrote:
Red rose lad wrote:
Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.
Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.
So Jonn admits that Milliband and Balls don't have a clue about the economy!

After all they were wrong about everything else, their last grasp at some sort of higher ground being the "cost of living crisis"!!
[quote][p][bold]Jonn[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Red rose lad[/bold] wrote: Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.[/p][/quote]Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.[/p][/quote]So Jonn admits that Milliband and Balls don't have a clue about the economy! After all they were wrong about everything else, their last grasp at some sort of higher ground being the "cost of living crisis"!! loan_star
  • Score: -4

7:09pm Wed 19 Mar 14

John Durham says...

David Lacey wrote:
And Miliband forgot to mention how his mates crashed the economy by 7.2% in 2008. Or ran up a record deficit and debt. Or let in record numbers of immigrants putting millions out of work. Or saw our education standards slip below most of the developed world.
.
Fact is it was a wickedly political budget that has Labour well and truly stuffed.
I'm not sure that many people believe this nonsense the government puts out though.
In any economy where employment levels were at a peak as this one supposedly is then productivity figures would also be high - they're not. Why? - because too many people are working less hours than they need or are on zero-hours contracts. Too many waiting for that text message Monday morning to see if they have any work.
Too many parts of the country where the benefits of this supposed growth are not reaching too. And growth based on the very causes of the crash in the first place - not real but unsustainable. Mark Carney only yesterday warning again that the economy could yet be in trouble if we continue this way.
What have we come to in this country? The bankers get their bonuses even when they've failed like useless football managers who keep getting appointed somewhere no matter how many times they mess up. And now Osborne - who promised to get rid of the deficit in this term but now its going to be another four years is patting himself on the back for his failure.
And after the next election what then? Back to austerity - you bought the bribe but now you have to pay for it? Meanwhile millionaire friends of George will be looking forward to a 40p tax rate while more and more of the services we need are diminished through neglect and more and more nurses and low paid providers of these services are forced onto income support. Back to the mess of the early 1990s.
And after four years in government, despite all these supposed extra jobs, still 2.3 million unemployed, still nearly a million young people unemployed.
Still too many using foodbanks, struggling to pay their bills and too many can't get a decent home after the worst housebuilding record of any government.
Are Labour truly stuffed? I very much doubt it really. People will see beyond the smoke and mirrors my friend.
[quote][p][bold]David Lacey[/bold] wrote: And Miliband forgot to mention how his mates crashed the economy by 7.2% in 2008. Or ran up a record deficit and debt. Or let in record numbers of immigrants putting millions out of work. Or saw our education standards slip below most of the developed world. . Fact is it was a wickedly political budget that has Labour well and truly stuffed.[/p][/quote]I'm not sure that many people believe this nonsense the government puts out though. In any economy where employment levels were at a peak as this one supposedly is then productivity figures would also be high - they're not. Why? - because too many people are working less hours than they need or are on zero-hours contracts. Too many waiting for that text message Monday morning to see if they have any work. Too many parts of the country where the benefits of this supposed growth are not reaching too. And growth based on the very causes of the crash in the first place - not real but unsustainable. Mark Carney only yesterday warning again that the economy could yet be in trouble if we continue this way. What have we come to in this country? The bankers get their bonuses even when they've failed like useless football managers who keep getting appointed somewhere no matter how many times they mess up. And now Osborne - who promised to get rid of the deficit in this term but now its going to be another four years is patting himself on the back for his failure. And after the next election what then? Back to austerity - you bought the bribe but now you have to pay for it? Meanwhile millionaire friends of George will be looking forward to a 40p tax rate while more and more of the services we need are diminished through neglect and more and more nurses and low paid providers of these services are forced onto income support. Back to the mess of the early 1990s. And after four years in government, despite all these supposed extra jobs, still 2.3 million unemployed, still nearly a million young people unemployed. Still too many using foodbanks, struggling to pay their bills and too many can't get a decent home after the worst housebuilding record of any government. Are Labour truly stuffed? I very much doubt it really. People will see beyond the smoke and mirrors my friend. John Durham
  • Score: -1

7:40pm Wed 19 Mar 14

Jonn says...

loan_star wrote:
Jonn wrote:
Red rose lad wrote:
Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.
Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.
So Jonn admits that Milliband and Balls don't have a clue about the economy!

After all they were wrong about everything else, their last grasp at some sort of higher ground being the "cost of living crisis"!!
Anyone who compares an economy to a credit card is an idiot. I think you'll find Osbourne has used the phrase on many occasion. As far as Milliband and Balls not having a clue, no they don't either.
And please stop attacking a criticism of the current Government by simply criticising the previous Government, that gets us nowhere.
[quote][p][bold]loan_star[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Jonn[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Red rose lad[/bold] wrote: Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.[/p][/quote]Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.[/p][/quote]So Jonn admits that Milliband and Balls don't have a clue about the economy! After all they were wrong about everything else, their last grasp at some sort of higher ground being the "cost of living crisis"!![/p][/quote]Anyone who compares an economy to a credit card is an idiot. I think you'll find Osbourne has used the phrase on many occasion. As far as Milliband and Balls not having a clue, no they don't either. And please stop attacking a criticism of the current Government by simply criticising the previous Government, that gets us nowhere. Jonn
  • Score: 0

8:40pm Wed 19 Mar 14

Daveindarlo says...

Living standards would of been down even further if labour had been reflected in 2010. It would of been for those of us who work. There'd of been no increase in allowance for ole earners. National insurance contributions would have increased . Council tax would of been higher as they would have not capped it.
They would of been boring more to pay ridiculous amounts of housing benefit.
Living standards would of been down even further if labour had been reflected in 2010. It would of been for those of us who work. There'd of been no increase in allowance for ole earners. National insurance contributions would have increased . Council tax would of been higher as they would have not capped it. They would of been boring more to pay ridiculous amounts of housing benefit. Daveindarlo
  • Score: 3

8:42pm Wed 19 Mar 14

Red rose lad says...

Jonn wrote:
Red rose lad wrote:
Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.
Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.
Oh dear John. The credit card was a simple analagy. Maybe I aimed too high.
[quote][p][bold]Jonn[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Red rose lad[/bold] wrote: Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.[/p][/quote]Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.[/p][/quote]Oh dear John. The credit card was a simple analagy. Maybe I aimed too high. Red rose lad
  • Score: -4

11:23pm Wed 19 Mar 14

behonest says...

Let's not forget that one reason for the 'cost of living' crisis that Labour say we are facing, is the maximum council tax increases forced on us by Labour councils.
Let's not forget that one reason for the 'cost of living' crisis that Labour say we are facing, is the maximum council tax increases forced on us by Labour councils. behonest
  • Score: 4

6:04am Thu 20 Mar 14

Jonn says...

Red rose lad wrote:
Jonn wrote:
Red rose lad wrote:
Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.
Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.
Oh dear John. The credit card was a simple analagy. Maybe I aimed too high.
An analogy the Government have been using to hoodwink simpletons and the ignorant, along with the lie 'all in it together', the patronising slogan 'hardworking taxpayers' and the lie of 'austerity'.
[quote][p][bold]Red rose lad[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Jonn[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Red rose lad[/bold] wrote: Dead right David. There's never any hint of an apology from Ed & Ed. How can we all expect to be doing better if we are paying off their maxed-out credit card. We can't keep giving when the bank is empty. Stan and Ollie just don't get basic economics. Brown may have been the worst PM in history but these two clowns were each "advising" him for over 10 years. The deficit occurred on their watch and their advice was a major part of the equation. Let's not take any lectures from this discredited pair whilst the nation is digging it's way out of the chasm which they helped to create.[/p][/quote]Comparing an economy to a credit card just shows you don't get basic economics either.[/p][/quote]Oh dear John. The credit card was a simple analagy. Maybe I aimed too high.[/p][/quote]An analogy the Government have been using to hoodwink simpletons and the ignorant, along with the lie 'all in it together', the patronising slogan 'hardworking taxpayers' and the lie of 'austerity'. Jonn
  • Score: 2

11:10am Thu 20 Mar 14

John Durham says...

behonest wrote:
Let's not forget that one reason for the 'cost of living' crisis that Labour say we are facing, is the maximum council tax increases forced on us by Labour councils.
That would work if it were only Labour councils which had raised council tax. But it isn't the case eg North Yorks.
And the root cause of those increases goes back to the government anyway as many councils of all political persuasions have said.
[quote][p][bold]behonest[/bold] wrote: Let's not forget that one reason for the 'cost of living' crisis that Labour say we are facing, is the maximum council tax increases forced on us by Labour councils.[/p][/quote]That would work if it were only Labour councils which had raised council tax. But it isn't the case eg North Yorks. And the root cause of those increases goes back to the government anyway as many councils of all political persuasions have said. John Durham
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree