Payments to struggling farmers must not be cut, warns North Yorkshire MP

The Northern Echo: Anne McIntosh Anne McIntosh

PAYMENTS to struggling farmers must not be cut further while their incomes are falling, a committee of MPs warns today (Tuesday).

The Government is urged to shelve plans to switch more Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) cash from direct payments to rewarding environmental care.

Ministers plan to increase the current rate of transfer from so-called Pillar 1 of CAP to Pillar II from nine per cent to 15 per cent.

But today’s report by the Commons environment, food and rural affairs committee says that will hurt “vulnerable” farmers earning as little as £8,000 a year.

Anne McIntosh, the Thirsk and Malton MP, and the committee’s chairwoman, said the threatened change came against a “background where farm incomes are falling”.

She added: “Cutting payments to these businesses will reduce their ability to compete in the marketplace and leave farmers less able to invest in vital infrastructure.

“It may make them more vulnerable to shocks such as poor weather, higher input costs and price variations.

“We recommend that the Government maintains the current nine per cent rate of transfer away from the direct payment budget.

“This rate of transfer should rise to 15 per cent in 2017 only if it can demonstrate that additional funds are required and that this change will deliver a clear benefit.”

The Government has come under fire for its negotiating of Pillar II funding, which saw the UK’s allocation fall, while handouts to France and Italy rose.

That means Pillar II spending in England would be 27 per cent lower by 2020, with the planned switch from Pillar 1.

Today’s report also urges the Government to:

  •  Use an “active farmer test” to ensure EU subsidies go only to people who “actually and actively run a farm business”
  •  Ensure farmers can also apply, and receive complicated guidance, “on paper” – despite a “digital by default” strategy.

Miss McIntosh added: “Farmers know from bitter past experience that the development of the new IT system will be a stand-out challenge for Government.

“A lot went wrong in the last round of changes, and these problems gave rise to £580m in penalties.

“With that in mind, we question whether it makes sense to introduce a new computer system at the same time as complex new payment rules.”

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:27pm Tue 3 Dec 13

The Grim North says...

Just scrap the CAP altogether and stop subsidising Framers full stop (French and Italian ones included). If they can't make money get off the land and let it go back to wilderness. If there are farmers out there only making £8,000 a year then I only feel contempt for them. Why carry on with a futile attempt to make money from an unprofitable industry when you could make more money stacking supermarket shelves.
Just scrap the CAP altogether and stop subsidising Framers full stop (French and Italian ones included). If they can't make money get off the land and let it go back to wilderness. If there are farmers out there only making £8,000 a year then I only feel contempt for them. Why carry on with a futile attempt to make money from an unprofitable industry when you could make more money stacking supermarket shelves. The Grim North

4:24pm Tue 3 Dec 13

sleeping dragon says...

only making 8k a year? they never seem to be without new gas guzzlers
only making 8k a year? they never seem to be without new gas guzzlers sleeping dragon

6:15pm Tue 3 Dec 13

DOGLAWRENCE says...

sleeping dragon wrote:
only making 8k a year? they never seem to be without new gas guzzlers
99% of the Hard up Farmers I see at my Local Auction Mart have Vehicles + Tractors less than Three Years Old so better Idea instead of Subsidising them give the Money to the Thousands of People who due to Benefit Reforms have to go to Food Banks for Food
[quote][p][bold]sleeping dragon[/bold] wrote: only making 8k a year? they never seem to be without new gas guzzlers[/p][/quote]99% of the Hard up Farmers I see at my Local Auction Mart have Vehicles + Tractors less than Three Years Old so better Idea instead of Subsidising them give the Money to the Thousands of People who due to Benefit Reforms have to go to Food Banks for Food DOGLAWRENCE

11:05pm Tue 3 Dec 13

spragger says...

The sooner we kill the CAP the better
Why we subside farmers, often to tend fallow fields, defies description
We are often taking money from poor taxpayers, to bung bucket loads of money at very rich landowners & farmers

A good reason for leaving the EU is to ditch the hopeless CAP & subsidies
The sooner we kill the CAP the better Why we subside farmers, often to tend fallow fields, defies description We are often taking money from poor taxpayers, to bung bucket loads of money at very rich landowners & farmers A good reason for leaving the EU is to ditch the hopeless CAP & subsidies spragger

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree