Ban on smoking in cars where children are passengers moves closer (From The Northern Echo)
For details on how to contact our editorial and commercial departments, click here
Ban on smoking in cars where children are passengers moves closer
3:50pm Wednesday 27th February 2013 in News
Prime Minister David Cameron has promised to "look carefully" at a proposal to ban smoking in cars when children are present
A BAN on smoking in cars when children are passengers moved a big step closer today, when David Cameron pledged to examine the idea.
The prime minister surprised MPs by agreeing to “look carefully” at the proposal along with other possible measures to further curb smoking in public places.
A day earlier, Anna Soubry, the health minister, threw her weight behind the plan, telling a conference: “I would ban smoking in cars where children are present.”
Any ban would represent an extraordinary victory for Alex Cunningham, Labour MP for Stockton North, who has led a two-year campaign for the move.
Mr Cunningham introduced his own private member’s Bill, warning that 300,000 UK children are taken to their GP with smoking-related illnesses every year.
One cigarette in the car - even with the window open - creates a greater concentration of second-hand smoke than a whole evening's smoke in a pub used to, research had found.
Yet, back in 2011, Mr Cameron dismissed Mr Cunningham’s plea for action, saying he was “very nervous about going into what people do inside their car”.
The Stockton North MP hailed the apparent U-turn, saying: “First the health minister confirmed what she has said privately, that she is in favour of a ban.
“Now the prime minister has said it will be looked at, which is shift from what he said to me a couple of years ago – when he gave me a flat no.
“Time will tell whether they are willing to match words with deeds, but the statistics speak for themselves.
“Thousands of children, each year, are forced to breathe second hand smoke in a confined space, with the obvious damage to health – and 86 per cent of children think there should be a ban.”
The issue arose at prime minister’s questions, when Gateshead MP Ian Mearns urged Mr Cameron to back Mr Cunningham’s Bill as a “significant step further” in protecting children.
In reply, he said: “I think we should look carefully at what he, and others, have said.
“We are looking across the piece at all the issues – at whether we should follow the Australians with the ban on packaging, what more we can do on restricting smoking in public places.
“We have to look at each one and work out whether there is a real public health benefit but I think he makes a good point.”
Later, the prime minister’s spokesman confirmed to Westminster journalists that the issue of second-hand smoke in cars would be examined.
Coincidentally, Mr Cunningham’s Bill is almost certain to be killed off tomorrow (FRI), because of a lack of parliamentary time.
However, its supporters are likely to seek an opportunity to tag the measure to other legislation – and see whether the government will back it.
More NHS & Health News
- Nursing union criticises new threat to privatise community services
- Survey finds a majority of North-East GPs are facing restrictions on new drugs
- Mock clinical trial highlights benefits of trying new drugs or treatment
- Public consultation over planned hospital changes gets under way
- Campaign tells patients that it is 'OK to ask' about clinical trials
- Maggie's Cancer Support comes to the North-East
- Ex-footballer urges everyone to bring dementia out into the open
- Poster girls promote NHS careers
- Study aims to discover whether special insoles can help MS patients walk
- Genetic medicine unit now seeing 800 new cases a year in bid to prevent inherited cancers
Comments(8)
behonest
says...
4:34pm Wed 27 Feb 13
Copley23
says...
4:36pm Wed 27 Feb 13
battboy77
says...
5:25pm Wed 27 Feb 13
Voice-of-reality wrote:Yeah thanks for all that!!!!!!! cant you just be glad for a positive move towards this type of ban without all that ramble???
Cameron's 'change of heart' has little to do with actually supporting the measure - it is more about the parliamentary timetable. In a situation in which the coalition in broken down with the Lib Dems blocking any overtly Conservative policy and v.v., the PM has to find a series of issues with which to fill parliamentary time - as the government cannot be seen to do absolutely nothing for two years - it is of course mandated to stay in power for the full five years. In reality, of course, that is precisely what is happening - as no 'pressing' policy initiatives can be initiated as a consequence of the voting deadlock between the parties. Expect therefore two years of 'fringe' policies - smoking, devolution, gay marriage - all issues that in one sense are unimportant (though paradoxically also fundamental from constitutional and liberty viewpoints) as a consequence of the two warring factions of government being unable to 'come together' to actually address the non-fringe issues that actually matter; such as the economy and the need to cut the welfare bill so that the country can afford to live. The effect of both the coalition and the fixed-term initiatives has been to introduce into the Westminster model a form of the 'lame duck' - that vexatious of issues that permeates the American model of democracy.
Voice-of-reality
says...
5:55pm Wed 27 Feb 13
NO EINSTEIN
says...
7:12pm Wed 27 Feb 13
your joking
says...
8:40pm Wed 27 Feb 13
Parmenion
says...
10:57pm Wed 27 Feb 13
It's a rhetorical question, but let's get to the facts...
The idea that there is no safe level of secondhand smoke turned the laws of science on their head. The first rule of toxicology is that the dose makes the poison. All substances are toxic at high enough levels just as they are harmless, even beneficial, at lower levels.
Most of us understand that coffee contains benzene, water contains arsenic and that televisions pump out radiation but we don't let it worry us since the levels of these highly carcinogenic toxins are too low to pose a threat to our health. Apparently only one substance disobeys this law of toxicology: secondhand smoke.
"As long as the government is perceived as working for the benefit of the children, the people will happily endure almost any curtailment of liberty and almost any deprivation."
Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf.
Voice-of-reality says...
4:31pm Wed 27 Feb 13