THERE are valid arguments for and against re-publishing the front cover of this week's edition of the Charlie Hebdo magazine, and here at The Northern Echo we have debated long and hard over which position to take.
We do not believe that bravery or cowardice defines that position. Nor do we share the view of some, on either side of the debate, that the decision is straightforward.
We completely support the right of the French satirical magazine to be free to make its own judgement to publish a front page cartoon of the Prophet Muhammad, in defiance of last week's Islamist terror attacks.
Ever since the killings in and around Paris, we have played our small part in supporting the Je Suis Charlie campaign, which has seen people all over the world stand up for the freedom of expression.
But that freedom should also respect the right of other publishers to take a different view.
It is a matter of fact that the image on the front of this week's edition of Charlie Hebdo is central to a major international news story and we, therefore, understand why some media organisations believe their readers and viewers should be able to see what all the controversy is about.
But that has to be weighed against the knowledge that publishing a cartoon of the Prophet will deeply offend some people.
There is nothing wrong with defending the principle of the freedom of expression while at the same time showing respect for the views and beliefs of others.
Imam Tahir Selby, a moderate, considerate Iman at a mosque in Hartlepool, has written a piece for The Northern Echo in which he speaks up powerfully in defence of free speech, condemns terrorism, but explains why depicting the Prophet is so offensive to Muslims.
In his piece, he respectfully asks The Northern Echo not to print the Charlie Hebdo cartoon but to use wisdom and judgement.
It is a fine line but we have exercised our freedom to decide not to print the cartoon. Many will disagree with that decision but it was not reached through fear or bowing to pressure.
It was reached through respect for the feelings and beliefs of the vast majority of decent, moderate Muslims like Tahir Selby.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article